Benjamin & Karen Noblitt v Bluegreen

Case Number: 3:18-cv-00117

Last Updated: May 29, 2023

Status

Settled while cross MSJs and cross MILs pending

Location

TN ED

Presiding Judge

Judge Mattive

Date Filed

03/21/2018

Highlights

Court denied motion to dismiss complaint based on merger clause, aka “license to lie:”

“Unlike contract law, tort law’s purpose is not to hold parties to the benefit of a bargained agreement. Instead, tort law seeks to impose societal duties that proscribe acceptable standards of conduct between individuals;”

Case Posture

Claims:

Viol of TN Timeshare Act, fraud, breach of contract

Posture:

Settled while cross MSJs and cross MILs pending

Selected Events:

March 20, 2019 Order [29] denying in part BG M2D: fraud based on vicarious liability sufficiently pled re “rental pitch, ” Barclay card w/ 15.9% interest; justifiable reliance on specific statements (not merely opinion/puffery), citing Rest (2d) of Torts § 649(2), cmt c (1977) (“a purchaser is justified in assuming that even his vendor’s opinion has some basis of fact, and therefore in believing that the vendor knows of nothing which makes his opinion fantastic”); and Rest (2d) of Torts § 538(2)(1977) re materiality. Disclaimer/merger clause (NO PURCHASER SHOULD RELY UPON REPRESENTATIONS OTHER THAN THOSE INCLUDED IN THIS AGREEMENT) does not immunize Ds fm fraud. “Unlike contract law, tort law’s purpose is not to hold parties to the benefit of a bargained agreement. Instead, tort law seeks to impose societal duties that proscribe acceptable standards of conduct between individuals;” SOL defense rejected based on delayed discovery rule; TN Timeshare Act provides a private right of action;

Click on the PDF titles below to view.

Docket link

Operative Complaint

Critical Orders

Critical Briefs

Transcripts

Click on the PDF titles above to view.

Parties

Plaintiffs:
Benjamin and Karen Noblitt

Plaintiffs’ counsel:
Aubrey Givens

Kristin Fecteau

 

Defendants:
Bluegreen

Defendants’ counsel:
Bradley Arant Boult Cummings (Brandon Bundren)

By using this site and its services you agree to the Terms of Service of this site.

By continuing to use this site you agree to these Terms of Service and acknowledge that you understand that you are agreeing to binding legal terms.